April 25, 2009
psychology today
After a week’s-worth of revelations about the U.S. torture program, have people changed their minds?
Nope.
Isn’t that odd?
Well, not if you know the story of Marian Keech. In the early 1950s, Keech, a Chicago housewife, started receiving mysterious messages from extraterrestrials, telling her that the world would be destroyed by a giant flood on December 21, 1954. However, by having faith in God, she and her 11 followers would be saved by a UFO. As you may recall from history class, the world was, in fact, not destroyed in a giant flood on December 21, 1954. So, what happened to the beliefs of the “Seekers” (as Ketch’s cult called itself)? Well, two members did leave when the prophesy went blatantly unfulfilled. But something strange happened with the rest: Their beliefs were actually strengthened. These people, after all, had made a significant investment in Keech’s being a prophet. Some had quit their jobs, sold their houses, given away their possessions. When 4:45 a.m. rolled around, with no UFO and no flood, Keech said she had a new revelation: God had spared the world because of the Seekers’ faith. Seekers poured into the streets, elated, grabbing passers by and trying to convert them. Soon after, the once-publicity-shy group started sending out press releases seeking to proselytize new believers.
(via andrew sullivan)
comments
Leave a Reply


This kind of thinking is utterly frustrating to me. When someone fails to put certain filters on what they will believe it becomes possible for them to believe all sorts of irrational things.
Didn’t the Seventh Day Adventists start the same way? I’m sure I heard of an established religion which started in a very similar fashion.
There’s nought so queer as folk.
“I think it’s better to have ideas. You can change an idea. Changing a belief is trickier. Life should malleable and progressive; working from idea to idea permits that. Beliefs anchor you to certain points and limit growth; new ideas can’t generate. Life becomes stagnant. “
Oops, that was Chris Rock in Dogma